Skip to main content

The Regulation Trap: Why Forcing Calm is Counterproductive





We live in a world that often praises hustle, immediate results, and "pushing through." This mindset, while sometimes effective in certain areas of life, can be incredibly detrimental when applied to the delicate art of nervous system regulation. Many well-intentioned individuals find themselves falling into "the regulation trap"; a cycle of forcing calm, growing impatient with the process, and ultimately giving up on practices that could profoundly benefit their well-being. I see this a lot in my work and with my clients. 

The truth is, attempting to force your nervous system into a state of regulation is not only ineffective; it's profoundly counterproductive. So why does forcing fail? It is actually quite paradoxical; our nervous system, specifically the Autonomic Nervous System (ANS), operates largely outside of our conscious control. It's an ancient, wise system designed for survival, constantly scanning our internal and external environment for cues of safety or threat. So, when we try to force ourselves to relax, to "just calm down," or to suppress uncomfortable sensations, we inadvertently send a different message to our system: "Danger! Our nervous system is receiving a message that something is wrong, and I'm trying to control it." 

This very act of "forcing" creates tension; an internal tension, that is registered by the nervous system as another stressor, perpetuating the very dysregulation you're trying to escape. As Stephen Porges, creator of Polyvagal Theory, notes, "Safety is not the absence of threat, but the presence of connection"; and forcing often severs our connection to our authentic internal state. Dr. Porges' concept of Neuroception explains this beautifully. Our nervous system unconsciously evaluates risk. When we consciously override or suppress our body's signals of discomfort, our neuroception can interpret this as a lack of safety. It's as if our body is saying, "I'm feeling anxious, alert!" and our conscious mind replies, "No, you're not! You're calm!" This internal disconnect creates more stress, not less.

Stepping away from forced relaxation requires a gentle, mindful approach. It is important to recognize the 'rebound effect': when we finally release the effort to force a sense of calm, the underlying anxiety or tension often springs back, sometimes with even greater intensity. This sudden surge can feel discouraging and may lead to a sense of defeat or the urge to give up on the practice entirely. For those navigating deep stress, working with a professional can provide the necessary support to navigate these moments. Having an expert to hold space and normalize these setbacks can be the difference between falling back into the trap and finding true, sustainable ease.

True regulation is an invitation, not a command. While the 'hustle' culture tells us to push harder, the path to a balanced nervous system requires us to soften. By understanding the importance of gentleness, acknowledging the rebound effect and seeking the right support, we can move past the cycle of frustration and toward a state of genuine safety.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

IS MINDFULNESS ESSENTIAL FOR WELLBEING?

  IS MINDFULNESS ESSENTIAL FOR WELLBEING?     What is mindfulness and how is it related to wellness? Well, in simple terms mindfulness is awareness! It is our ability to be fully present in the moment we are in, aware of what is happening around us and what is happening within us, while accepting our experience as is without judgment! Professor Jon Kabat Zin (founding Executive Director of the Center for Mindfulness in Medicine, Health Care, and Society at the University of Massachusetts Medical School) and developer of MBSR (Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction) program) defines it as “… paying attention in a particular way; on purpose, in the present moment, and non-judgmentally.” It is a purposeful attention that gives us the opportunity to pause, reflect and then decide how to act, creating a space within us to respond rather than react.    Mindfulness has been shown to have significant psychological and physiological benefits when properly taught and practice...
Post a Comment
Read more

What is the relationship between mindfulness and eating habits?

Mindfulness is our ability to remain present in the moment we are in and be aware of what is happening around us (external environment and stimuli) and what is happening within us (emotional state, feelings, body sensations and physical cues). Practicing mindfulness help improve our awareness increasing our attention to external stimuli that may be affecting our eating habits and to our internal emotional state that may be the root cause of our eating habits!  There is significant research proving that mindfulness techniques improve unhealthy eating habits and develop a more positive and healthy relationship with food. Weight gain, in certain cases is a result of emotional eating and without awareness of the root cause of this habit, it will be more challenging to break or change it! Studies have also reported that mindfulness practice can reduce physiological distress such as depression, anxiety, stress, and eating behaviors including binge and emotional eating.  In...
Post a Comment
Read more

POWER YOGA AND HEALTH

       Having its roots set in Ashtanga yoga, Power yoga is an intense and vigorous type of yoga that was created in the west in the 1990’s. Unlike Ashtanga however, it does not follow a set series of poses, and therefore Power yoga classes vary. This allows some to find it more fun as opposed to the classical kind and is believed to have been created to make yoga more accessible to the people in the west. It is evident that interest in yoga has flourished during the past decade and yoga has now become an addictive lifestyle that many are following. Some people consider yoga a trendy movement and try it out because others are! However, I believe this addiction is directly related to the health benefits that yoga provides. Power yoga, as with other types of yoga, provides both physical and mental health benefits. Some are evident such as flexibility and strength, while others are subtler and require a commitment to regular and longer periods of practice.   ...
Post a Comment
Read more